Review: TIFF 2016: ‘The Exception’ should be the rule in historical drama (Includes first-hand account)

Historical dramas almost always run the risk of being dry, expansive pictures that fail to find the balance between entertaining and informing audiences. Of course it’s important to know and understand the past, but the advantage of film is it can be more enjoyable than a textbook or classroom. A movie is permitted flourishes for theatrical effect and some leeway regarding events in the narrative in order to adequately convey the real-life incidents. Even adapting a story from a book can require some adjustments to engage theatre audiences. The Exception is almost an anomaly in this area in that the historical recreation manages to do all of these things correctly.

Capt. Stefan Brandt (Jai Courtney) is considered a disgrace to his German uniform by many, yet he’s been provided a second-chance following a severe combat injury. His assignment is to take command of the soldiers guarding Kaiser Wilhelm II (Christopher Plummer) who was exiled to the Netherlands after WWI, which is now under German control. In addition to protecting the head of the displaced monarchy, Brandt is to spy on his activities and visitors. However this assignment has some quirks because in spite of being a very likeable man, the Kaiser has few reservations about saying what’s on his mind in front of anyone, including criticizing Hitler and the Third Reich. Nonetheless, most of the captain’s attentions become focused on Mieke de Jong (Lily James), a servant girl who is smart, attractive and harbouring secrets of her own.

This film gives a brilliant script to incredibly capable actors, who effectively convey the drama, humour and tragedy of the characters and their situation. Courtney and James have wonderful chemistry, conveying their affection for each other in even the most restrictive conditions with a simple glance or smirk. Their dedication to their conflicting duties, regardless of the harm it may cause the other combined with the instinctive knowledge that neither would allow harm to befall the other, is the recipe for a classic and captivating love story.

Meanwhile at 87, Plummer still has enough charm and wit to singlehandedly capture an audience’s attention for an entire picture. He consistently and inadvertently dominates every scene with the Kaiser’s candid observations and sharp intellect. He also receives notable support from Janet McTeer, who plays his more cautious wife determined to find their way back to the throne in Berlin with the assistance of their loyal subordinate, portrayed by a very regal Ben Daniels.

While most of the film’s events are removed from the horror in Germany and surrounding countries, the invasion does drag some of the violence into the Dutch backyard. From soldiers ransacking the Kaiser’s country home for evidence of a potential spy to brutal interrogations for the same information to atrocious news of the “progress” being made by the Nazi death machine, the former monarchy is slowly made to realize Germany is no longer the same country they left all those years ago. A visit from Heinrich Himmler (Eddie Marsan), head of the SS, is preceded by great hope of good news, but is quickly soured as he delivers his own version of good tidings and further proves Brandt’s capacity for empathy is not shared by his comrades.

David Leveaux is an award-winning theatrical director, but this is his first foray behind the camera. Nonetheless, his experience generates expertly led dialogue and a strong sense of space in a select number of locations. For instance, the distinction of a rendezvous in one bedroom versus another is not lost in the narrative nor is the distinction of how one utters such nuanced dialogue as “Take off your clothes” followed by a camera that doesn’t discriminate between male and female nudity. Leveaux’s attention to detail and how an audience perceives a scene is quite keen.

The film had its world premiere at the Toronto International Film Festival. Don’t miss the rest of our TIFF 2016 coverage.

Director: David Leveaux
Starring: Christopher Plummer, Lily James and Jai Courtney

Similar Posts

  • Review: Oscar-nominated doc ‘Last Days in Vietnam’ offers unique account (Includes first-hand account)

    The Vietnam War presented a unique situation for the United States in that they had technically lost the battle. The Paris Peace Accords proclaimed a ceasefire between North and South Vietnam, ending direct U.S. military involvement and resulting in the majority of American troops going home save for a small military faction and contractors. However when the communists resumed their invasion of southern territories with brutal efficiency after President Richard Nixon’s resignation, the American government was faced with a number of decisions as were the men still assigned to the region. Last Days in Vietnam is a documentary about the days that followed the initial attack.

  • Review: TIFF 2018: ‘Jeremiah Terminator LeRoy’ is who they want him to be (Includes first-hand account)

    Freud talked a lot about how people develop their personalities, what they consist of, and how they’re presented to the outside world. Many believe we are a sum of our experiences, while others think we can choose what people see. Identity is an essential part of the human existence, though its truth can often be debated — particularly whether one person can claim to have more than one identity. In Jeremiah Terminator LeRoy, this is taken even further as two women begin to share a third identity.

  • Review: Hot Docs’ ‘Show me the Funny’ showcases stand-up & sketch comedy (Includes first-hand account)

    Almost everyone loves to laugh. Studies even show there are health benefits to a regular chuckle. There are entire television networks dedicated to broadcasting humorous content. It’s a mystery why some people are professional-grade funny and others are less so; it’s often a practiced craft, but for some it just comes naturally. The Hot Docs Canadian International Documentary Festival serves audience’s appetites for comedy with the program, “Show me the Funny.” Amongst this year’s selections is a film about three men who persevere in a struggling industry and another is a behind-the-scenes look at one of the world’s most famous comedy troupes.

  • Review: ‘Mustang’ gains deserved recognition for spirited portrait (Includes first-hand account)

    Being a girl or a woman remains a challenging prospect, but it’s even more difficult in certain parts of the world and in cultures where gender prescribes specific expectations and dictates your position in society. Double standards are far more prevalent in these areas as males are basically free to behave as they wish and any responsibility of wrongdoing is immediately thrust upon the females who are demanded to exhibit more control. But the irony of these situations are increasingly less accepted as borders become less finite and more liberal thinking is able to pass through. Mustang is the story of five young women trapped in the purgatory between evolution and deep-rooted tradition in Turkey.