Review: TIFF 2017: ‘The Captain’ is the unsettling story of an imposter (Includes first-hand account)

It would seem the angles from which a film can look at war and its atrocities are endless. There’s the three basic perspectives of the two opposing parties and the citizens caught between, but each of these have countless possibilities from administrative and frontline roles to patriotic or conscripted soldiers to compliant or rebellious populations. Moreover, the many nuances available to each character confirm the complexities of conflict as well as continuously fascinate audiences. In The Captain, a young German soldier in WWII finds the world is his oyster after a lucky break near the end of the war.

While it’s not known exactly what occurred between Herold (Max Hubacher) and his commanding officer, their last encounter leaves him hiding in the woods and scavenging for food. Desperate and cold, he happens upon an abandoned jeep with some food and a trunk containing a captain’s uniform. Deciding to take his chances, Herold assumes the appearance of an SS officer and practices his sneer. The first soldier he meets buys the ruse, emboldening the imposter and setting him on a path of greater subterfuge and undeniable cruelty. While many would come to question Herold’s methods, no one ever truly suspected his authority or rank.

Herold is quite the singer, but an even more convincing actor. After getting over his initial butterflies, he allows the power of the uniform to fill his brain and takeover his demeanour. Likely spending his enlistment envying the influence of his superiors, he relishes the opportunity to carry that clout himself. Moving from one location to the next, he reasserts his authority in each new encounter and grows his company under the guise of a special mission personally assigned by the Führer. However, where he starts by winning over people with mercy or kindness, he becomes increasingly ruthless and needlessly cruel, mirroring the callous attitude of one of his earlier recruits.

Shot in bleak black and white, writer/director Robert Schwentke returns to his native Germany for this raw and chilling story about a German deserter who ran for his life, not his principles. In spite of primarily making action movies of late, Schwentke has an absolute grasp of the landscape and sentiments of these months preceding the end of the war. Moreover, Hubacher’s genuine portrayal of a young man who transitions from survivalist to another cold-blooded arm of the Third Reich is exceptional. Combined, they deliver a picture that is compelling yet shocking — feelings only enhanced by the conclusion, which couldn’t be more appropriate.

The Captain had its world premiere in the Special Presentations category at the Toronto International Film Festival. Don’t miss the rest of our TIFF 2017 coverage.

Director: Robert Schwentke
Starring: Max Hubacher, Milan Peschel and Frederick Lau

Similar Posts

  • Review: Hot Docs finds happiness in less than 60 minutes (Includes first-hand account)

    Happiness comes in many shapes and sizes, as do documentaries. Although the average movie is between 90 and 120 minutes long, a film is considered feature-length at more than 40 minutes. While there aren’t many fictional narratives that hover around this runtime, documentary filmmakers are seemingly more comfortable not padding a picture to reach an unnecessary but more widely accepted duration. The Hot Docs Canadian International Documentary Festival‘s “The Pursuit of Happiness” programme includes two of these shorter format movies: Dugma: The Button and Up or Out.

  • Review: ‘Backcountry’ uses nature’s monster to provide its scares (Includes first-hand account)

    Mother Nature and wild animals can be as unpredictable as they are deadly. Confronting either without experience or the right equipment is more than ill-advised — it’s dangerous. The Boy Scouts’ motto is “always be prepared” for good reason; because anything less can be a death sentence. A couple discovers just how treacherous the wild can be in Backcountry.

  • Review: ‘The Mummy’ needs its priorities reordered (Includes first-hand account)

    It’s no longer unusual to see studios looking for new ideas to reach back into their histories and reboot old ideas or franchises. For many who’ve watched the originals, this ranges from a minor irritation to an outright offense. But the reality persists and it’s arguably unfair to judge a movie before watching it, or to carry preconceptions into a screening. So (almost) every picture deserves a fair shake, but then it’s open season. The latest film up for reboot judgement is The Mummy and it seems there may have been a good film in there somewhere.

  • Review: Ian McKellen is the most relatable ‘Mr. Holmes’ (Includes first-hand account)

    It’s difficult to imagine our heroes growing older and becoming less competent. They often seem as if they would remain ageless and infallible forever. This is only true of fictional characters, but they also provide an opportunity to address these issues through a personality with which people are already familiar and perhaps attached. It allows for a different perspective on the story and negates the necessity to build a connection because one already exists. Mr. Holmes features an aged Sherlock desperate to solve one last case.