Review: ‘Fifty Shades of Grey’ focuses on one conventional tone (Includes first-hand account)

Probably one of the most hotly anticipated Valentine’s weekend releases in history, just the presale tickets for Fifty Shades of Grey were enough to green light its two sequels and guarantee the trilogy would be completed on screen. Even the majority of early reviews had a positive slant, which undoubtedly gave Universal Pictures the confidence to commit to producing two more golden eggs. But the book had many critics — and for good reason — so how does the film improve on such a hot mess?

Anastasia Steele (Dakota Johnson) was just doing her roommate, Kate (Eloise Mumford), a favour when she agreed to interview Christian Grey (Jamie Dornan) for the graduation edition of their university newspaper. No one would have guessed that the two would share an immediate spark. But Christian isn’t looking for a traditional relationship and the inexperienced Ana wasn’t really aware of the existence of anything else. As each tries to impose their ideals of a couple on the other, neither can emerge the victor.

The greatest benefit director Sam Taylor-Johnson and writer Kelly Marcel have in making the film is not being tied to E.L. James’ mind-numbing, repetitive, adolescent prose. Thankfully they take full advantage of this separation, incorporating a minimum of the ludicrous dialogue verbatim (particularly references to Ana’s “inner goddess”) while retaining the essence of the protagonists’ interactions. They’ve made other important changes as well, which speak to some of the other criticisms of the source material: they eliminate the constant reiteration of Christian’s need to “own” Ana and they replace her little girl demeanour with a slightly stronger, more assured version of the character.

However, none of these modifications remove the inherently objectionable aspects of the narrative. It remains a limited representation of BDSM in which Taylor-Johnson continues to treat the audience with the same naiveté of “non-vanilla sex” as the book, but with even less detail than the original (see the introduction to Christian’s playroom, a.k.a. “the red room of pain”). Though they’ve softened the implication in the film, Christian’s stalker, power-hungry behaviour generally borders on abuse or harassment — an element on which they could have seized the opportunity to address on the screen rather than suppress and gloss over it. (Where are all of Kate’s worrying interjections?)

Which finally brings us to the actors. Johnson has a solid understanding of her character and how she needed to be changed for the big screen. Though she still encompasses all of Ana’s innocence, she’s not as mousy or weepy as she is in the novel. This allows for the impression that she’s excited to — rather than somewhat coerced into (Christian admittedly uses sex as a weapon) — finally exploring her sexuality, even if she’s chosen the most incompatible partner. On the other hand, Dornan is completely ill-suited for the part. He lacks the physical and emotional severity demanded by the role, and is clearly more comfortable enacting the romantic fantasies than the kinky ones. Charlie Hunnam was probably an equally poor choice, but we’ll never know. Personally, I’ve always pictured an Alexander Skarsgård-type.

The first 90 minutes of the film is dedicated to the playful, sensual nature of their budding relationship; conversely, the last 30 minutes plunge quickly into the darkness that’s been constantly nipping at the seams. Still, in the end the adaptation is a comprehensible, albeit mostly conventional, romance with a little more skin than the average mainstream love story.

Director: Sam Taylor-Johnson
Starring: Dakota Johnson, Jamie Dornan and Eloise Mumford

Similar Posts

  • TIFF 2015: Director and actor go with the flow in ‘River’ (Includes interview and first-hand account)

    Writing and directing one’s first feature-length film is already a daunting task, but setting it in a communist country halfway around the world is an added challenge that could have had mixed results. Jamie M. Dagg’s thriller, River, is set and shot in Laos, which was no vacation in spite of the exotic location. In addition to the “stifling heat,” there was “very little film infrastructure,” says Dagg. At the same time, “all these little things that seemed insurmountable problems contributed to the film.” The film’s star, Rossif Sutherland, agrees that the limitations were blessings in disguise; “We couldn’t have done it with a bigger budget and crew because we would have been too noticeable… You stick a crane in there and you lose the quality of what it is to be in that place.”

  • Review: Murder permeates this week’s releases

    This week’s releases include a cat-and-mouse chase at the edge of fire; an Australian political drama; a new chapter of the Midnight Society; a classic tale of murder; an all-star ensemble; a look at life in diapers; and a still enduring horror franchise.

  • Review: The best reason to have a ‘Bad Reputation’ (Includes first-hand account)

    One of the great things about film in recent years is their increased (and somewhat begrudging) willingness to tell female stories. In some cases, it’s hard to believe they weren’t told before and in others it’s easy to see they couldn’t have been told correctly until now. But as others have said, seeing oneself on-screen is a powerful thing and women at the forefront have been grossly underrepresented in spite of comprising half the world’s population. That, of course, doesn’t mean they haven’t been doing great things — just that no one was sharing them with the masses. In Bad Reputation, audiences learn about Joan Jett‘s barrier-smashing music career.

  • Review: ‘The Finest Hours’ is a tale of bravery in many circumstances (Includes first-hand account)

    It’s fair to say even the dangerous jobs were more hazardous 50 years ago. New safety measures and equipment improvements have decreased the mortality rates of most risky positions. But in some cases there are just certain threats and vulnerabilities that can’t be extinguished with Mother Nature topping the list of unmanageables. Whether those employed in these industries do it for the money, sense of duty or lack of other opportunities, the risk is the same. In The Finest Hours, a U.S. Coast Guard team heads out into a horrendous storm to rescue the crew of a sinking oil tanker.