Review: ‘Mustang’ gains deserved recognition for spirited portrait (Includes first-hand account)

Being a girl or a woman remains a challenging prospect, but it’s even more difficult in certain parts of the world and in cultures where gender prescribes specific expectations and dictates your position in society. Double standards are far more prevalent in these areas as males are basically free to behave as they wish and any responsibility of wrongdoing is immediately thrust upon the females who are demanded to exhibit more control. But the irony of these situations are increasingly less accepted as borders become less finite and more liberal thinking is able to pass through. Mustang is the story of five young women trapped in the purgatory between evolution and deep-rooted tradition in Turkey.

Lale (Günes Sensoy) and her four sisters (Doga Zeynep Doguslu, Elit Iscan, Tugba Sunguroglu and Ilayda Akdogan) are nearly inseparable. Raised by their grandmother (Nihal G. Koldas), they’re a little more uninhibited than is considered acceptable by certain neighbours but they’re generally good kids. However, some innocent horseplay with some of their male classmates on the last day of school has unexpected and catastrophic results. Rumour spreads quickly and they’re suddenly considered harlots by the rest of the town. Their uncle (Ayberk Pekcan) goes to great lengths to save their marriage prospects, most of which involves barricading them in the house. Soon the “wife factory” is turning out finished product, but Lale refuses to submit to their outdated practices.

The youngest of the girls, Lale is the feistiest. She speaks her mind, orchestrates more than one escape and learns to drive a car all in an effort to find freedom from the lifelong servitude imposed upon them. While imprisoned, the girls dutifully clean the house, learn to cook various traditional recipes and allow themselves to be fitted for drab-coloured, shapeless dresses. In their downtime, their playfulness turns to solemnity and they dream of rejoining the world outside their door. The only time they are seen outside the house during their infinite sentence is to be paraded as eligible marriage material and then when they’re wedded to whoever requests their hands.

The first half of the film is quite similar to Sofia Coppola’s The Virgin Suicides as the tightknit sisters’ guardians overreact to their spirit in spite of their innocence and confine them to their home; though it lacks the former’s moody soundtrack. Boys lament their removal from society, windows serve as a bridge to the world beyond and the escalating strictness threatens their sanity. But this film goes beyond unsympathetic adults being irrationally overprotective because their actions and reactions are deeply ingrained in a culture that approves of such extreme measures. When girls are thought to have broken the rules, this is how they should be dealt with — though some of the elder women discreetly demonstrate their disagreement with secret gestures of solidarity and support.

Writer/director Deniz Gamze Ergüven’s feminist portrait is a powerful depiction of the harm caused by these young women’s unjust treatment. The intimacy she achieves by capturing their secret expressions and private moments throughout the picture allow the audience to become invested in their lives and empathize with their situation. Viewers’ hearts will race with theirs as their acts of rebellion are nearly discovered on several occasions and things to come to a dangerous head in the film’s conclusion. Yet we are also seduced by their virtue, strength, beauty and promise shown through natural and purposeful cinematography. Lale is the perfect narrator for the story — seen through her spirited eyes, their hope for a better life never truly dies.

Director: Deniz Gamze Ergüven
Starring: Günes Sensoy, Doga Zeynep Doguslu and Elit Iscan

Similar Posts

  • Review: ‘Never Look Away’ finds inspiration in all of life’s experiences (Includes first-hand account)

    Since the conclusion of World War II, storytellers have approached the conflict and its fallout from numerous perspectives. Some are less direct than others, opting to follow the path of someone not immediately involved, but affected nonetheless. The repercussions of that particular war were long-lasting as the hunt for high-ranking officials that played key roles in Hitler’s design continued for decades. Consequently, it was often the children who felt the burden of their parents’ sins in post-war Germany. In Never Look Away, life behind the communist wall becomes too difficult to bear.

  • Review: ‘Knives Out’ keeps the mystery alive with a classic whodunit (Includes first-hand account)

    A great murder mystery keeps audiences guessing, even as the suspect pool shrinks and all evidence points to one person — there’s always that shadow of a doubt the narrative clings to and nurtures. Whodunits are always fun to watch, or even play, because they rely on so many senses and skills, from keen observation and attention to detail to gut instincts. Moreover, the characters are generally over-the-top personalities who almost always have a motive linked to greed, revenge or both. Then there’s the shrewd detective tasked with solving the crime à la Sherlock Holmes. Knives Out delivers all these elements in an intriguing, yet funny package.

  • Review: TIFF 2019: ‘Kuessipan’ is about the strength of female friendship (Includes first-hand account)

    Based on historical circumstances, groups of people are pigeonholed into certain types of narratives. That’s not to say those stories aren’t true, but there’s also an argument to be made that other tales are equally true. For Indigenous people, movies often focus on the difficulties of maintaining their traditions, injustices perpetrated by the government, the impact of residential schools, the disproportionate rates of addiction and suicide, and other “problems.” But they’re also just people with jobs, families, relationships, dreams and regular stories to tell. In Kuessipan, two young women from the same Quebec Innu community find they have less in common the older they become.