Review: ‘Ad Astra’ doesn’t have the right stuff (Includes first-hand account)

We have only explored a fraction of the universe and have yet to even come close to inventing the technology postulated in many science fiction movies. Thus, the genre has the freedom to make its own path and go anywhere the filmmakers’ imaginations take them. In recent years, some have opted to keep it simple by focusing on a lone character in space, while others have revisited monumental events in history. Still others choose to look towards an even more distant future in which advancements in space travel have made the impossible possible. This is the world in which Ad Astra unfolds.

Thirty years ago and 15 years into his mission on Neptune, Clifford McBride (Tommy Lee Jones) lost contact with control and was presumed dead. He was labelled a national hero. His son, Roy (Brad Pitt), followed in his footsteps and became one of the best astronauts in the program. He’s built a reputation on staying cool under pressure and keeping his emotions in check. Now, some remnant of his father’s assignment is threatening the solar system and it’s up to Roy to try to stop a universal catastrophe with the help of one of his dad’s former colleagues (Donald Sutherland).

In its simplest form, this is an action movie set in space. Unfortunately, it doesn’t adapt well to its environment. There is a high-speed chase on the moon as space pirates attempt to overtake Roy’s convoy. Unfortunately, a lack of traffic, other obstacles, loud noises and gravity makes what sounds cool unexpectedly dull. It’s at this point one realizes this probably isn’t going to be the picture’s only issue. From the not-so-well-kept secrets of the original mission to Roy’s impulsive response to the ultimate solution to the problem, the formula may have been transplanted to a different locale but the ingredients remain the same. In spite of all its predictability, the movie takes time to appreciate the wonder of space and its infrastructure. The flipside is the picture is unnecessarily long.

Roy’s self-control requires Pitt to give a somewhat robotic performance, which goes against everything that makes the actor alluring. Moreover, when his unemotional façade does crack, it seems unnatural. Most of the other characters have so little screen time, it almost all lands on Pitt’s shoulders. It’s not until the final act, when Jones steps into the picture that the movie finds its spirit, but by then it’s too late.

Take a new journey into space when you experience James Gray’s @AdAstraMovie in #IMAX theatres. Out this Friday. Reserve your seat: pic.twitter.com/zTvSXU61cN

— IMAX (@IMAX) September 16, 2019

Director: James Gray
Starring: Brad Pitt, Tommy Lee Jones and Ruth Negga

Similar Posts

  • Review: TIFF 2019: ‘Spider’ shows you can never really escape the past (Includes first-hand account)

    In the age of the internet and social media, there is a permanent record of almost everything. But there was once a time when the sins of your past could be buried and the only chance of it resurfacing was someone spilling the beans or inadvertently coming across evidence. For those who eventually rose to positions of power or found legitimate success, this is a danger that constantly lurks on the horizon and threatens to potentially destroy everything they built. Unfortunately, leaving the past in the past isn’t always a unanimous decision. In Spider, the third point of a triangle returns and his former partners do everything they can to silence him.

  • Review: ‘Guardians of the Galaxy Vol 2’ is awesome like your fave mixtape (Includes first-hand account)

    Taking a chance on a lesser known Marvel property paid off in spades a few years ago when the studio introduced mass audiences to the Guardians of the Galaxy. A flawless cast endeared viewers to these previously unfamiliar characters and the old school soundtrack had them grooving in their seats, all while writer/director James Gunn‘s script entertained, engaged and left everyone wanting more. With the release of Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2, their calls have been answered with glorious humour, action and dancing.

  • Mama review: TIFF 2025

    ‘Mama’ is the sharp portrayal of a woman suddenly struck by the impact working abroad has on her role as matriarch.

  • Review: ‘Under the Shadow’ is frightening before the monster even arrives (Includes first-hand account)

    Living under the constant threat of violence or death in a war-torn city is probably more frightening than any scary story or horror movie. Pulling neighbours from the rubble of the latest onslaught and being forced out of one’s home because it’s unsafe to spend another night becomes the norm rather than the exception. G.K. Chesterton’s famous quote says that fairy tales were created to demonstrate monsters can be killed… but what if their other purpose was to warn people of the creatures’ existence and instruct them on how to triumph? In Under the Shadow, a woman realizes there are even more things to be afraid of as she tries to protect her daughter from missile strikes and whatever is lurking in the shadows.

  • Review: ‘Moana’ isn’t letting anything stand between her and her mission (Includes first-hand account)

    Disney has always been ahead of the curve when it came to featuring female protagonists in their animated features. However, more importantly, the types of women portrayed and their narrative trajectories have evolved over the years; though it’s been most noticeable in the last decade. The princess is no longer hunting for a husband or waiting for a prince to save her from her evil relatives or a witch’s spell — she’s going on dangerous quests and vowing to save others. She has become the master of her own destiny and found the strength within herself to accomplish great things. Moana is the epitome of this evolution.