Review: ‘The Strangers: Prey at Night’ is a massacre instead of thriller (Includes first-hand account)

In the movie industry, “leaving well enough alone” isn’t a phrase that carries much weight. Even when it seems like they’ve struck lightening by achieving an acceptable level of acclaim or success, it’s just a reason to recycle and repeat. Usually this happens in the form of a remake or an immediate sequel, capitalizing on whatever formula worked the first time around. However, occasionally (though more frequently as of late), someone decides to continue a story years after the original. The narrative time that’s past is often comparable to the gap between films and in most cases the original characters return for another go. The latest follow-up to an older movie is The Strangers: Prey at Night.

A family is going on an unpleasant road trip to drop their delinquent daughter, Kinsey (Bailee Madison), at boarding school. Dad (Martin Henderson) is trying to keep the peace, while mom (Christina Hendricks) insists this is their only option and brother Luke (Lewis Pullman) resents being dragged along for the ride. But before they part ways, they’re spending the night at their Uncle Marvin’s off-season trailer park… and they’re not the only ones. A mysterious girl knocks at their door in the middle of the night looking for her friend. Then a man in a mask is seen standing outside their window. And that’s just the beginning of what will be the worst night of their lives… if they survive.

The first film was all about atmosphere. The Strangers stalked the couple for hours, frightening them into a state of hysteria and forcing them to take risks out of desperation. Without being gory, it harkened back to the horror films of the ‘70s that were nearer to psychological thrillers than the torture porn that was pervading cinemas. It was intense, disturbing and audiences really responded to the film. Cut to 10 years later and they can’t seem to replicate that formula.

The movie starts in a way that will be very familiar to fans of the original. The still active trio of killers (though they are played by different actors: Emma Bellomy, Lea Enslin and Damian Maffei) wear the same masks, drive the same truck and use the same tactics to do recon on their latest victims. However, it seems a decade of murder has enhanced their lust for blood so the deaths are less drawn out and more malicious. Of course with a family of four their fun continues if they kill one or two early on, but it gives the movie a different tone.

sorry not sorry… #PreyAtNight pic.twitter.com/zkADfCib3E

— The Strangers (@TheStrangers) March 7, 2018

The picture relies on a lot of horror movie clichés to propel its narrative, as well as a couple of difficult to believe coincidences. But most egregiously, what filmmakers likely thought was an homage to one of the greatest ‘70s horror movies plays more like a rip-off that tanks a movie already on the brink of losing genre fans.

Director: Johannes Roberts
Starring: Christina Hendricks, Bailee Madison and Martin Henderson

Similar Posts

  • Review: ‘Tenet’ is a time-bending thriller that keeps you in the loop (Includes first-hand account)

    After approximately six months of not going to movie theatres, it’s not surprising studios are trying to lure audiences back with high-profile films that had pre-established hype. Big pictures with big names are definitely an advantage in this re-emerging market as the many delayed release dates are finally coming due. In 2000, writer/director Christopher Nolan had a breakthrough indie success, becoming a filmmaker to watch — and boy did we! Twenty years later, the mere mention of his name piques interest and conjures expectations of grand complexity. His latest film, Tenet, is a time-bending, action adventure that will keep viewers on their toes.

  • Review: ‘Lights Out’ is scary in all the right places (Includes first-hand account)

    It’s not the actual darkness that frightens most people, but whatever danger may be lurking in the black void that they can’t see – and therefore can’t effectively defend against. Whether real or supernatural, we’re taught from an early age to be cautious of things that go bump in the night. Moreover the ancient dichotomy of light and dark is ingrained in our consciousness, inherently teaching that one is good and the other bad. Horror movies often exist in the shadows, taking advantage of these impulses and the lack of visibility to tell scary stories. Lights Out is one of the best concepts to leverage these fears in cinema.

  • Review: ‘The Predator’s only problem isn’t its name (Includes first-hand account)

    There is a prevailing sentiment that any contact with an alien race will be generally unfriendly and probably violent. The expectation is that there will be no interest in making peace or sharing knowledge; instead, there will be a war over resources and in spite of advanced alien technology, humans will prove triumphant via their sheer will to survive. One can only hope that if there is intelligent life out there, they don’t access our entertainment and judge our species inhospitable. Thirty years ago, Arnold Schwarzenegger starred in a movie about a space warrior that came to Earth to earn his stripes. More have come since and now they’re back in The Predator.

  • Review: ‘Mistress America’ wears its crown proudly (Includes first-hand account)

    Divorce is a recurring subject in fiction. Even though it’s no longer true that 50 per cent of marriages fail, it was at some point. However re-marriage and the blending of families is portrayed less often, unless in the form of a family-friendly comedy. Being an adult suddenly connected to another adult because of a choice made by your parents is a strange proposition; though it could also be an exciting opportunity to bond with someone who you otherwise would never have met. Both are true in Mistress America, which features a whirlwind sisterhood.