A scene from ‘Anatomy of a Fall’

TIFF ’23 Review: ‘Anatomy of a Fall’ breaks a marriage down to its worst moments

‘Anatomy of a Fall’ is a ruthless court procedural that scrutinizes every aspect of a woman’s life when she’s accused of killing her husband.

Sandra (Sandra Hüller), Samuel (Samuel Theis) and their visually-impaired son Daniel (Milo Machado Graner) moved to a secluded house in France not long ago. She’s a successful writer and he’s a professor — a literary power couple on paper. One day, Daniel returns from taking his dog on a winter walk to find his father’s body lying in the snow at the side of the house. He screams for his mother who calls emergency services, but it was too late — Samuel was dead. But how did he die? Was he pushed from the balcony? Did he jump out the window? With an inconclusive autopsy, it’s up to the court to decide if Sandra murdered her husband, while their son learns all the gritty details of their imperfect marriage.

Every transgression, rumour or work of fiction the prosecutors deem relevant is submitted for consideration. Regardless of whether viewers think Sandra is guilty or not, it’s tough not to sympathise as they analyze intimate details of her life with Samuel and she’s forced to defend things that would normally go undetected or be forgotten. Consequently, watching the case unfold is emotionally trying as one can only imagine being put in a position to defend words said in the heat of the moment or refute subjective accounts of your personality and actions. As the only other witness, Daniel becomes a participant in the trial, though it’s interesting to watch them walk a tight rope during his questioning.

Setup as a courtroom drama, audiences will become engrossed in the intense trial as Sandra’s personality awaits a verdict.

Anatomy of a Fall had its Canadian premiere in the Special Presentations programme at the Toronto International Film Festival.

Read other reviews from the festival.

Director: Justine Triet
Starring: Sandra Hüller, Swann Arlaud and Milo Machado Graner

Similar Posts

  • Review: ‘Arrival’ is the sincerest type of science fiction (Includes first-hand account)

    As NASA regularly announces the discovery of distant planets with life sustaining environments, it’s easy to wonder what an encounter with alien life may look like. In addition to the aliens’ possibly strange appearance, how would we communicate with them? Would they come in peace? How would they arrive? Originally the answers to these questions were envisioned in science fiction books, then they moved to films. Without knowing anything about what may be out there, the possibilities of an encounter are infinite. Arrival is the latest picture to imagine what could happen if Earth received visitors from outer space.

  • Review: ‘The Good Liar’ is a tricky film that doesn’t always fool viewers (Includes first-hand account)

    The elderly are often targets of scams as their potential loneliness and lesser understanding of technology or finances can make them vulnerable to people waiting in the wings to take advantage. It’s an unfortunate reality that can lend itself to interesting fiction, particularly when marriage is involved. Younger people are often characterized as gold-diggers when they become romantically attached to much older, well-off widows/widowers. However, The Good Liar proposes money can be a motivating factor at any age.

  • Review: ‘Love the Coopers’ is smothered in sugary melodrama (Includes first-hand account)

    The end of the year seems to elicit films about dysfunctional families trying to spend the holidays together, and collections of loosely related stories of people trying to find love and happiness in the chaos; the proliferation of these narratives is likely inspired to some extent by the popularity of National Lampoon’s Christmas Vacation and Love Actually respectively. However most pictures fail to recreate the success of either. Love the Coopers has decided to try to capture the essence of both styles.

  • Review: ‘Woman in Gold’ depicts a single victory of stunning consequence (Includes first-hand account)

    After a war ends, its effects ripple through several generations as survivors attempt to reclaim a sense of normalcy and their struggles are imprinted on their children. Their experiences become a part of history, taught in classes and read in books; but there is still a human aspect that demands reparations. The repercussions of WWII has persisted for more than half a century as families and supporters continue to seek justice for wrongs committed. One of the most publicized is the attempts to recoup personal property confiscated/stolen by the Nazis, which includes priceless works of art “recovered” after the war by museums and private collectors — many pieces still remain unaccounted for as well. Woman in Gold is the story of a woman who wants to be reunited with a portrait of her aunt, but doing so involves removing it from an Austrian museum.