A scene from ‘Napoleon’

Review: ‘Napoleon’ falters just as its subject did

‘Napoleon’ recounts the life of the historical figure, peeking behind the uniform at the even smaller man who filled it.

Countless historical figures are known to people, though they may only be familiar with their greatest achievements or failures. After all, that’s the reason their names are etched into our collective memories and textbooks. But those events do not necessarily define the person or serve as accurate reflections of their personalities and values. In some cases, the truth may diminish the legend or fortify it because they defied the odds to obtain glory. Napoleon is recognized for his military cunning, but a new biopic from director Ridley Scott shows his personal character left much to be desired.

Napoleon Bonaparte (Joaquin Phoenix) did not come from noble blood, but his family ran in the right circles and befriended the correct people to give him a chance at greatness. Beginning as an artillery master, he used his brilliant military strategies and ruthlessness to rise through the ranks, eventually earning the title of general. While he kept his ambition quiet, he did not protest much when it was suggested he appoint himself Emperor of France. Unfortunately, Napoleon started believing his own propaganda about his invincibility, leading to several military breakdowns, his abdication and, finally, exile.

The film covers approximately 30 years of Napoleon’s life, from his early career to his eventual death in exile on an island off the coast of Africa. It includes many battles, from the Siege of Toulon to an Egyptian expedition to his disastrous invasion of Russia and ultimate failure to regain the throne. The conflicts are violent and bloody with cannons dealing horrific damage, demonstrating Napoleon’s inventive military strategy and revealing the tens of thousands of casualties left on the field when the smoke cleared. However, while these campaigns were shot practically to show their epic brutality, they are not the film’s focus, comprising a less significant portion of the narrative than the leader’s personal affairs.

This movie sets out to expose the aspects of Napoleon not seen on the battlefield — namely, his insecurity in every other aspect of his life, which often made him vindictive and willing to double down on bad ideas just to further establish his dominance. His letters to his first wife, Josephine (Vanessa Kirby), are exceptionally vulnerable for a man in his position, exulting his devotion to her as she unabashedly cheated on him while he was away, fighting for his country. Even the manner in which he spoke about other leaders often revealed an impetuousness that bordered on a child’s scorn.

Phoenix does an excellent job portraying both sides of the French leader. It’s easy to see why Scott would cast him since Napoleon’s personality is very similar to Phoenix’s role as Commodus in 2000’s Gladiator. Nonetheless, not much is made of Napoleon’s height in the film, even though it’s his most publicized attribute, only standing head to shoulder to a few of his counterparts throughout the picture.

Unfortunately, at 158 minutes, the film doesn’t sustain audience’s attentions as they gradually lose interest in Napoleon’s softer side, and the story becomes somewhat repetitive and trifling.

Director: Ridley Scott
Starring: Joaquin Phoenix, Vanessa Kirby and Rupert Everett

Similar Posts

  • Review: TIFF 2017: ‘The Captain’ is the unsettling story of an imposter (Includes first-hand account)

    It would seem the angles from which a film can look at war and its atrocities are endless. There’s the three basic perspectives of the two opposing parties and the citizens caught between, but each of these have countless possibilities from administrative and frontline roles to patriotic or conscripted soldiers to compliant or rebellious populations. Moreover, the many nuances available to each character confirm the complexities of conflict as well as continuously fascinate audiences. In The Captain, a young German soldier in WWII finds the world is his oyster after a lucky break near the end of the war.

  • Review: ‘Miss Bala’ is an uncommon display of a woman’s fortitude (Includes first-hand account)

    A strong female lead doesn’t have to be a well-trained, lethal weapon ready to strike at any moment. She doesn’t need to be muscular or look a certain way. And she doesn’t have to be fighting her enemy every minute to demonstrate her resilience – or overcoming a sexual assault for that matter. As fear can easily overwhelm patience, sometimes biding one’s time requires more courage than jumping at the first opportunity for escape or retaliation. There’s more than one way to become a survivor or prevail under seemingly impossible circumstances. In Miss Bala, a young woman is swept up into a Mexican gang war and does what she must to stay alive.

  • Review: ‘Tracers’ uses parkour to enhance the film’s appeal (Includes first-hand account)

    There seem to be increasingly fewer ideas to keep chase and heist movies fresh. The elaborate planning of Ocean’s Eleven and high-speed pursuits through crowded city streets are becoming clichéd and uninspired. However by incorporating new physical disciplines, a conventional plot can be raised to new, more energetic levels. Tracers uses parkour to enhance its otherwise traditional narrative.

  • Review: TIFF 2018: ‘The Wind’ blows the house down (Includes first-hand account)

    Watching scary movies or reading frightening books when alone at night can lead to your senses and imagination playing tricks to which you may not otherwise pay attention. Suddenly, the slightest noise or shadow takes on a sinister quality that could threaten your safety… even though the rational part of your brain insists there’s nothing skulking in the dark corners of the room waiting for an opportunity to strike. And in the morning it all seems rather silly, but in the moment it couldn’t feel more real. In The Wind, a young woman starts to feel as if she’s surrounded by evil in the remote, uncultivated Midwest.