A scene from ‘Death of a Whistleblower’

TIFF ’23 Review: ‘Death of a Whistleblower’ is a tricky puzzle to assemble

‘Death of a Whistleblower’ requires viewers’ undivided attention to pick up the miniscule breadcrumbs and uncover a dangerous conspiracy.

Some people are faced with difficult decisions when they’re just trying to do their jobs. Coming across evidence of wrongdoing at your workplace is a heavy burden to carry as it comes with the choice of whether or not you should do anything about it. Historically, those who have spoken out against cover-ups by government, military or large corporations have faced stiff penalties for their actions, even if they’re publicly heralded for their bravery. In some cases, these honest citizens risk or lose their lives for doing what’s right. In Death of a Whistleblower, such a casualty spurs a deeper dive into corruption.

Struggling to publish real news at her current publication, investigative journalist Luyanda Masinda (Noxolo Dlamini) can’t help but entertain an offer from an old friend, Stanley Galloway (Rob van Vuuren), to work on a top-secret, high-profile story. But when he’s killed in a targeted attack, she cannot let his death be for naught. Luyanda makes contact with Stanley’s inside man, Albert (Irshaad Ally), and begins to recreate the trail Stanley was following. What she uncovers is bigger than she imagined, spanning decades and involving top ranking officials. But the closer she gets to the truth, the more dangerous the path becomes.

This is a well-paced thriller that captivates audiences with a mystery and high stakes. However, at a little over two hours, it loses steam in the middle when it enters into a formulaic loop of finding evidence and being threatened. Nonetheless, as the story unfolds, it becomes apparent there are two crimes that have become linked over time. One took place more than 20 years ago and was swept under the rug. It, however, laid the groundwork for the felonies being committed presently, which involve chemical weapons and a covert arms dealer masquerading as a philanthropist. It’s not difficult to see why someone would be willing to kill to keep these secrets, though Luyanda’s stays of execution are not exactly aligned with their mercilessness.

While the conclusion is foreshadowed, giving audiences the opportunity to predict the film’s outcome, it is still a slightly unexpected turn of events. With some tightening, the narrative wouldn’t risk losing its viewers midway through the picture and the thrill element would be more evenly distributed. That said, it’s necessary to pay attention to the details — and there are many — or risk losing the progression of major plot points as the inquiry relies largely on connecting the minute dots. But the payoff is a shockingly complex subterfuge with frightening consequences if not exposed.

Death of a Whistleblower had its world premiere in the Centrepiece programme at the Toronto International Film Festival.

Read other reviews from the festival.

Director: Ian Gabriel
Starring: Noxolo Dlamini, Irshaad Ally and Kathleen Stephens

Similar Posts

  • Review: ‘Clouds of Sils Maria’ is a grand achievement times three (Includes first-hand account)

    Aging is a tricky business, both inside and out. Within someone may feel younger than their birth age, whether it’s a natural part of their personality or an effort to retain certain benefits of youth. Physically that person may be confronting the effects of gravity, lifestyle and nature; or perhaps it’s a younger appearance that actually informs their energetic personality. And then there’s the perception of others, which one can only influence but never fully control. In Clouds of Sils Maria, three women confront these issues and others while preparing for a notable production.

  • ‘The Boy Next Door’ quickly loses its appeal (Includes first-hand account)

    There are people that measure the quality of a neighbourhood based on the friendliness of its community. Morning hellos, block parties, barbecues and play dates paint a picture perfect scene. But considering most violent crimes are committed by someone you know, perhaps sociability isn’t always a good thing. In The Boy Next Door, a woman’s dinner offer invites much more than she intended.

  • Review: TIFF retrospective screens Maurice Pialat’s most successful film (Includes first-hand account)

    French cinema is historically a source of visceral narratives that don’t shy away from provocative subjects. Although director Maurice Pialat struck out at and from his contemporaries, the former painter was undoubtedly a product of the zeitgeist. His fascination with sexuality, Parisian families and tyrannical male figures underlies most of his work and is a reflection of many other French filmmakers; while his realist approach has often been compared to John Cassavetes. The TIFF retrospective, “Love Exists: The Films of Maurice Pialat,” demonstrates the many ways Pialat tackled these subjects in his films, though his most successful would be À nos amours.

  • Review: ‘Leatherface’ is justly confident in its portrayal of an icon (Includes first-hand account)

    As movie studios continue to reach back in time for inspiration and content, many are taking a small step away from the direct remake to create background stories for well-known characters. While these narratives are related to the popular films that made these personalities famous, they still allow an abundance of room for creativity when constructing the previously unknown but perhaps hinted at origin stories. The latest in this rising trend is Leatherface, which travels to a time long before the chainsaw-wielding maniac ever struck fear in the hearts of road trippers.