A scene from ‘Dune: Part Two’

Review: ‘Dune: Part Two’ takes a drastically different, yet still divisive, approach

‘Dune: Part Two’ continues the science fiction saga that follows a young duke on his path to lead a rebellion and regain his family’s position.

Frank Herbert’s Dune is an award-winning, classic sci-fi saga with so many moving parts, it’s impossible to capture all of the nuances in a standard two-hour film. Thus, it’s been adapted into miniseries and multi-part movies in an attempt to incorporate as much of Herbert’s universe as possible. Some of the details that make it so difficult to portray on screen are the complex political, scientific and social models that compel almost every action in the narrative. So, filmmakers can either get bogged down in trying to explain it all or opt for a high-level overview supplemented by new character arcs. In Dune: Part Two, director Denis Villeneuve chooses the latter.

Paul (Timothée Chalamet) and his mother, Jessica (Rebecca Ferguson), successfully embedded themselves amongst the Fremen, mostly thanks to Stilgar (Javier Bardem), who believes they could be the manifestation of a long-held prophecy, and Chani (Zendaya), who teaches him the way of her people. As the pair reluctantly accept their roles as messiah and Reverend Mother respectively, the war for the spice and control of Arrakis rages on. Beast Rabban Harkonnen (Dave Bautista) is struggling to maintain the Baron’s (Stellan Skarsgård) support as his ability to harvest the spice is repeatedly frustrated by Fremen attacks led by the newly named, Muad’Dib. So, his uncle redistributes the planet’s control to his other nephew, Feyd-Rautha Harkonnen (Austin Butler), who has a much colder approach to ending the conflict, which will force Paul’s hand and possibly bring forth the devastating Holy War he’s foreseen in his dreams.

This film is clearly influenced by the 1962 epic adventure drama, Lawrence of Arabia, which told the real-life story of a British soldier that played a significant role in the Arab Revolt. There are scenes in Villeneuve’s movie that strongly resemble those in its predecessor from Paul’s overwhelming reception by the Fremen to him leading them into battle against the occupying House Harkonnen. Moreover, though Herbert wrote the original story in 1965, it’s not surprising to see parallels between the movie and current world conflicts, pitting indigenous peoples against invading forces.

The first installment of this series attempted to establish the various houses and the reasons for tensions between them, losing some viewers as it conveyed the complexities of their relationships and the significance of their conflicts within the big picture. This second part disregards most of the story’s nuances in favour of stunning action sequences that engulf the screen with battles and explosions, and feature the mightiness of the monstrous worms that inhabit the planet. The sound rumbles through the IMAX seats and immerses audiences in the cinematic spectacle. For anyone not familiar with the source material, the movie will seem less confusing and more enjoyable. Conversely, fans will be disappointed by all that’s glossed over, altered or omitted completely.

Yet, the most upsetting change is made to Chani’s character and her relationship with Paul. In Herbert’s book, she’s supportive of Paul’s cause and they openly discuss the hard decisions he will have to make if he continues down this path. In the film, Chani explicitly opposes Paul’s actions and he behaves very uncharacteristically towards her, fostering trust issues between them. While there are many changes to the narrative, including a much briefer timeline that modifies the entire existence of some characters, driving a wedge between Paul and Chani is the most egregious. In their attempt to give Chani more agency and strengthen her character, they lose one of Paul’s foundations and most important confidante.

Villeneuve has mentioned making a third film based on Herbert’s second book, Dune Messiah, but so much that is at the centre of that narrative has been removed from this story, it’s difficult to imagine how the two could be reconciled.

Director: Denis Villeneuve
Starring: Timothée Chalamet, Zendaya and Rebecca Ferguson

Similar Posts

  • Review: Jack O’Connell continues trend of skillful silence in ‘71’ (Includes first-hand account)

    The chaos and confusion experienced in a mob causes people to make ill-advised decisions that can result in harm to themselves or others. Getting carried away in the situation or restricting one’s focus to a single detail can have equally damaging consequences. But some of these responses often seem uncontrollable in the heat of the moment. In ’71, a soldier performing crowd control becomes lost in enemy territory.

  • Review: ‘The Assistant’ bears everything that brought about the MeToo era (Includes first-hand account)

    As various industries and organizations remove their blinders to acknowledge the systemic sexism, harassment and abuse that’s existed for decades without consequence, the types of narratives being told are also changing. Rather than movies that portray this as the norm, films in the MeToo era are now giving voice to the victims and demonstrating such behaviour elicits harm in ways beyond the obvious. These accounts also illustrate the many obstacles to filing a complaint, pressing charges and/or getting people to even believe the accusations. In The Assistant, a young woman is burdened with being a bystander to her boss’ many transgressions.

  • Review: ‘Ready Player One’ is the film version you didn’t know you’d like (Includes first-hand account)

    Imagining the future, even by just a few decades, can create an endless string of exciting possibilities. The further into the unknown one ventures, the less their hypotheses need to be grounded in reality. Conversely, extrapolating from the now (or then) can help audiences connect with the narrative in a way not otherwise possible. Ernest Cline relies on a whole generation’s obsession with nostalgia in order to tell his sci-fi fantasy — and the movie version of his bestselling novel, Ready Player One, comprehends this attraction with great acuity.

  • Review: ‘Bill & Ted Face the Music’ is excellent to each viewer (Includes first-hand account)

    More often than not, our favourite movies are those that can be watched over and over again without losing their charm. It doesn’t necessarily make them cinematic accomplishments or the best movie of the year, but it means their ability to entertain us is enduring. Trying to recapture that appeal in a sequel is tricky business – especially if it’s decades later. Thirty-one years ago, audiences were introduced to Ted Theodore Logan and Bill S. Preston, Esquire as they travelled through time to pass high school history and one-day save the future. In Bill & Ted Face the Music, they’re still waiting for that crucial moment when their music will unite the world and the future is growing impatient.