Review: Neill Blomkamp’s ‘Chappie’ still has some major glitches (Includes first-hand account)

Artificial intelligence in its current and imagined states is a rich system in which to speculate and postulate the future of technological advancement via science fiction narratives. In most cases the proposal includes world domination and/or destruction, reflecting an inherent human fear of mechanization. But fewer storytellers attempt to guess what integration might look like. In Chappie, writer/director Neill Blomkamp tells the tale of a robot who can learn to be human.

Before the invention of Deon’s (Dev Patel) robotic police force, Johannesburg was a city of insurmountable crime. Now, in 2016, it’s once again habitable and Deon is a hero to everyone but his company’s rival inventor, Vincent (Hugh Jackman), whose project is losing ground and funding. However Deon is not satisfied with his tactically trained guardians; he’s been secretly working on a program that would give a machine true consciousness. A series of events lead to the newborn robot christened Chappie (Sharlto Copley) ending up in the possession of a group of gangsters who hope to use their new toy in the heist of a lifetime.

In a recent interview, Blomkamp said that he has a self-identified flaw: he is excellent at developing concepts for stories, but can be so caught up in the idea that he proves less focused on constructing an effective narrative to convey said concept to a wider audience. Though the filmmaker was referring to his sophomore outing Elysium, the same explanation can be applied to his third film. Separated into its individual parts, one can clearly identify the various ideas Blomkamp was trying to merge in this film; and the special effects are spectacular with seamless CGI bringing the robot to life, as well as impressive action sequences. Unfortunately the end result is messier than many moviegoers will be willing to tolerate.

A.I. is at the centre of the narrative, which explores a fascinating possibility. Deon’s creation enters the world essentially a newborn. Chappie has no knowledge of the world and although he is a fast learner, he must still be initially taught as if he was a small child. As a result, Yolandi and Ninja become his surrogate parents. While she resembles a doting mother trying to protect her new charge, he views Chappie as just another machine. Chappie refers to them as “mommy” and “daddy,” and Deon is his “maker.” Deon tries to instil his invention with morals and creativity, Yolandi loves and encourages him, and Ninja teaches him to be gangsta complete with walk, hand gestures and weapons training. He hopes to turn Chappie into “the best gangster on the block.” The contrast in their lessons demonstrates the chief dilemma with Deon’s design: in the wrong hands, a robot with a blank slate could be disastrous.

Casting Ninja and Yolandi Visser of the South African rap-rave group Die Antwoord makes an interesting pairing of gangster culture and science fiction that’s rarely been seen (with the exception of Attack the Block). According to an interview with Ninja, Blomkamp was interested in working with the duo but they were uncomfortable portraying roles too removed from their stage personalities. So when the filmmaker was developing this film, he was inspired by the possibilities of Chappie being influenced by these characters. The over-the-top versions of the real-life performers contributes humour and cruelty to the narrative that is unique to them and the situation.

The weakest aspect of the picture is the injection of Vincent as the story’s villain. Jackman’s oddball, mullet-wearing, hostile ex-soldier seems incredibly out of place and awkward. His character is key to instigating the final showdown — which is visually striking — but any part he plays in the overall tale is generally unwelcome. Each time his character takes the screen, it virtually stops the narrative flow because his story is superfluous to the central one. Incorporating this character’s actions into other parts of the script could have greatly improved the film’s cohesiveness.

Blomkamp also pays homage to the many robot sci-fi films that came before him. A section of the score used throughout the movie is similar to one of the main Terminator themes. Vincent’s robot is operated in a manner similar to the Jaegers in Pacific Rim. Elements of Robocop are incorporated into the story and even Short Circuit has some influence.

Separated into its individual parts, the film can be quite captivating. However as a whole, it unfortunately appears disorganized and ill-conceived. As a result many Alien fans are concerned about Blomkamp’s direction of a new addition to the beloved franchise, but maybe he’s finally learned his lesson.

Director: Neill Blomkamp
Starring: Sharlto Copley, Dev Patel and Hugh Jackman

Similar Posts

  • Review: TIFF retrospective screens Maurice Pialat’s most successful film (Includes first-hand account)

    French cinema is historically a source of visceral narratives that don’t shy away from provocative subjects. Although director Maurice Pialat struck out at and from his contemporaries, the former painter was undoubtedly a product of the zeitgeist. His fascination with sexuality, Parisian families and tyrannical male figures underlies most of his work and is a reflection of many other French filmmakers; while his realist approach has often been compared to John Cassavetes. The TIFF retrospective, “Love Exists: The Films of Maurice Pialat,” demonstrates the many ways Pialat tackled these subjects in his films, though his most successful would be À nos amours.

  • Review: ‘The Mortuary Collection’ makes funeral homes even creepier (Includes first-hand account)

    The horror anthology is a long-standing genre tradition. Sometimes the short stories share a common thread, and other times the only connection between tales is the framing story. Sometimes they are all written by a single storyteller, and other times it’s a collaborative effort between multiple writers and directors. Sometimes the collections are a good mix of quality scares and eerie atmospheres, and other times one or all of the stories fall short of being good. Yet the promise of a creepy compilation of scary stories keeps fans coming back for another try. The Mortuary Collection is a horror anthology that unsurprisingly originates in a funeral home.

  • Review: ‘Under the Shadow’ is frightening before the monster even arrives (Includes first-hand account)

    Living under the constant threat of violence or death in a war-torn city is probably more frightening than any scary story or horror movie. Pulling neighbours from the rubble of the latest onslaught and being forced out of one’s home because it’s unsafe to spend another night becomes the norm rather than the exception. G.K. Chesterton’s famous quote says that fairy tales were created to demonstrate monsters can be killed… but what if their other purpose was to warn people of the creatures’ existence and instruct them on how to triumph? In Under the Shadow, a woman realizes there are even more things to be afraid of as she tries to protect her daughter from missile strikes and whatever is lurking in the shadows.