A scene from ‘Profile’

Review: ‘Profile’ is visually innovative, but narratively flawed

Profile uses a new and emerging film genre to explore a social phenomenon, but should have put a little more thought towards the characters’ arcs rather than solely focusing on the format.

Investigative journalism is a cornerstone of news media and social accountability. From following endless paper trails to expose scandals with sweeping repercussions to going undercover to get first-hand accounts of covert criminal activity harming the community, these reporters perform an important role in society. Driven by their commitment to truth and justice, they endure long hours, brave dangerous encounters, and navigate complex structures and relationships to get the story. However, there’s always the risk of becoming precariously consumed by a subject to the point of making unwise and potentially unsafe decisions. In Profile, a young journalist infiltrates a terrorist recruitment ring, but gets alarmingly wrapped up in her alias.

Amy (Valene Kane) is a British freelance journalist trying to pitch a story linked to the growing number of young European women converting to Islam and leaving their homes to join jihadist wars in other countries. Learning many of these women are contacted over social media, Amy creates a fake profile to get the inside scoop. It’s not long after publishing and interacting with the right posts that someone takes the bait. Working with a news organization, she begins to record regular Skype conversations with an attractive, charismatic man named Bilel (Shazad Latif) who gradually earns her trust and confesses his love. Soon, it’s unclear how deep Amy has gone down the rabbit hole and if she will ever return.

In the same vein as Unfriended and Searching, the entire picture unfolds in the Screenlife format — in other words, on a computer or phone screen. This presentation style is particularly fitting for this film since almost all of Amy’s interactions — personal, professional and the blurred in between — occur on her desktop or smartphone. Director Timur Bekmambetov actually pioneered this format, having produced the aforementioned movies before taking the helm himself for this film. Although this style of filmmaking was introduced prior to the pandemic, it has taken on far more significance under current circumstances as most of our interactions have shifted from in-person to some form of technology. In addition, it’s easy to relate to Amy’s on-screen multitasking as she simultaneously speaks to her editor, searches for information and makes notes via multiple windows.

To an outside observer, it’s very obvious Amy allowed herself to be enchanted by the recruiter. Initially very cautious, she begins to let her guard down and engage in potentially risky idle chatter. She starts to push away all the people connected to Amy and embrace this faux personality, focusing on building a connection rather than teasing out clues for her news piece. Consequently, it’s not difficult to predict how the film will end if the viewer remains vigilant.

Kane and Latif competently carry most of the picture, though it can be difficult to stay engaged in Amy’s behaviour as she strays further from her mission. However, just as the viewer may start drifting, something occurs to draw them back into the narrative. Staring at a computer screen for 106 minutes does occasionally become tedious — especially if that’s already your primary daily occupation — but the story is probably more engaging than some other everyday tasks and it can be somewhat interesting to see how someone else interacts with their technology.

In the end, the film superficially shines a spotlight on this compelling and ongoing phenomenon, while also trying to demonstrate how these young women are groomed and lured — though perhaps a protagonist with a different background/occupation whose gullibility was more plausible may have better served the narrative.

Director:  Timur Bekmambetov
Starring: Valene Kane, Shazad Latif and Christine Adams

Similar Posts

  • Review: ‘The First Purge’ gets at the heart of the horror (Includes first-hand account)

    According to this franchise, in the near future the United States will condone one night of complete lawlessness. For 12 hours, every American citizen has the right to do whatever they want, including rape, murder and steal. But how could such a heinous event be permitted, let alone supported, by not only the people but their government? We’ve seen a family held hostage in their home, people wandering the streets in masks brutally killing anyone they encounter, disgruntled employees taking revenge on their bosses… and armed military units using the event as cover for the genocide of hundreds of lower income citizens. The First Purge is the story of how it all began.

  • Review: ‘Promising Young Woman’ passes judgement where justice fails (Includes first-hand account)

    To this day, a segment of society finds women with power problematic. More notably, they find women who take power uncouth and even frightening. A woman who seeks to level the playing field or — heaven forbid — gain the upper-hand, is a threat to the status quo and thus a threat to the patriarchy. Therefore, when a movie portrays this change in dynamics, but doesn’t adhere to the way these situations have typically been portrayed, it’s deemed to be lacking or false. If a woman is going to assume a position of power, it has to be in a manner that is expected and, consequently, acceptable because it was designed by men. Promising Young Woman throws all of that out the window.

  • Review: ‘Appropriate Behavior’ introduces a fresh female voice in cinema (Includes first-hand account)

    While new faces in cinema are a dime a dozen, a combination of freshness and competence is more difficult to find. But Desiree Akhavan’s feature debut is yet another hands-down success from a first-time female writer/director/actor. She follows in the footsteps of Lake Bell in 2013 (In a World…) and Gillian Robespierre in 2014 (Obvious Child) as a woman to watch behind the camera rather than just rising stars in front of it. Appropriate Behavior is an original narrative exploring the pitfalls of being an insecure, partly closeted, bisexual, Iranian woman in New York.

  • Review: Hot Docs provides new perspectives on familiar subjects (Includes first-hand account)

    Anyone looking for a film festival’s top offerings need to look no further than its “Special Presentations” section. At the Hot Docs Canadian International Documentary Festival, organizers collect all the films with high profile directors and/or subjects here with 34 selections this year. From celebrities from all walks of life to controversial issues to prolific documentary filmmakers, this programme has it all. We look at three films from this category: Lo and Behold: Reveries of the Connected World, My Scientology Movie and Trapped.

  • Review: ‘High-Rise’ is a spectacular failed social experiment (Includes first-hand account)

    When one looks back at particular eras or segments of history, they can often give the impression of one big social experiment conducted by a great unknown. The questions that seem to be asked most frequently are, “How far can we take this?” and relatedly, “How long will people allow this to continue?” The answers are often frightening and may cause the observer to doubt humanity’s ability or will to survive, and yet the past appears to be treated as a how-to guide rather than a reminder of earlier mistakes. In High-Rise, a mini-society forms in the confines of a London building; but its social hierarchy invites a chaotic repetition of days gone by.