A scene from ‘Simulant’

Review: ‘Simulant’ presents a stimulating but stale debate

‘Simulant’ is a science fiction thriller that deliberates the rights of humanoid androids, but doesn’t present any fresh arguments.

While science fiction movies have proposed the dangers of artificial intelligence (AI) for decades, we’ve only recently entered an age where the applications of AI can be directly seen in our lives. Less obviously, it makes our cars safer and enables autonomous driving features, personalizes our in-app recommendations, improves the realism in video games and makes our homes smarter. Now, with the likes of ChatGPT, people are actively using AI daily to complete any number of tasks and answer questions. In the meantime, teams of people are working on humanoid androids that incorporate AI to move around, have conversations and display emotions. It is the latter that informs the world of Simulant, which features an evolved future of artificial humanoids.

Humanlike androids populate every aspect of this world. Early, less sophisticated models can be seen performing domestic chores and service jobs. However, the latest models are indistinct from the actual humans amongst whom they live. Their appearance, speech and mannerisms are completely natural. The only thing that sets them apart are presets that make them obedient and incapable of harm. However, someone is giving simulants absolute autonomy and Agent Kessler (Sam Worthington) has been tasked with preventing the robots from achieving mass consciousness. Faye (Jordana Brewster) and Evan (Robbie Amell) are an upper-class couple who are experiencing a disconnect, but it may not be easily repaired. Casey (Simu Liu) arrives with a solution to their problem, though who it’s meant to help most isn’t entirely clear.

The Canadian film from director April Mullen treads some familiar territory in the debate between man vs. machine. The story explores various existential questions of being – if it feels, is it not alive? If the simulant carries the memories of a once living person, is it effectively that person? If you don’t believe in God or a soul, is there a difference between a human and a simulant? If there is no difference, should humans have the ability to command simulants? All of these questions are raised throughout the course of the movie, but it doesn’t provide any clear answers — in fact, it may further complicate the issue. Unfortunately, the film doesn’t cover any new territory. The whole premise may actually seem a bit familiar if you watched the TV series, Humans.

Nonetheless, the cast does well to navigate the issues and provide a solid foundation on which to wage the debate. They each represent a different aspect of the argument with varying stakes, their futures dependent on which side triumphs. Fortunately, the film doesn’t try to simplify the intricacies of the treatment of simulants, leaving it to audiences to decide which side, if either, is more valid.

Director: April Mullen
Starring: Robbie Amell, Jordana Brewster and Simu Liu

Similar Posts

  • Review: ‘The Danish Girl’ is a striking biopic about the relevant past (Includes first-hand account)

    Gender stereotypes and expectations still plague society, influencing how children and adults interact at play and in business. Discussions about gender are relatively new to Western culture, while its fluidity has been long accepted in other parts of the world. While broadcasting one’s sexuality is still considered a coup — though less and less necessary — announcing one is transgender remains a less acceptable concept. The Danish Girl focuses on a young man in the 19th century who gradually realizes his exterior form is not aligned with his interior thoughts and feelings.

  • Review: ‘The Longest Ride’ goes on far too long (Includes first-hand account)

    Good love stories are a hot commodity in Hollywood. It doesn’t always have to be realistic because sometimes it’s the unfathomable nature of their union that makes the couple so enticing. Shakespeare’s star-crossed lovers theme consistently emerges in one way or another as two people fall in love in spite of every odd betting against their success or even compatibility. Yet they persevere and audiences are treated to an ending fit for a fairy tale. Many of Nicholas Sparks‘ romance novels follow this formula and have been adapted for the screen; The Longest Ride is one more to add to the list.

  • Review: ‘Personal Shopper’ is Kristen Stewart’s best thus far (Includes first-hand account)

    Living one’s life on what feels like borrowed time and spending it looking for something doesn’t make for much of a life. The former causes a person to feel like anything they might try to do of significance will ultimately be pointless, while the latter keeps them preoccupied and consequently distracted from ever trying. The result is constant uncertainty and listlessness. Thus in Personal Shopper, the protagonist is on an aimless path that is hijacked by a self-serving force.

  • Op-Ed: Top 10 films of 2016

    Film critics watch a lot of movies. Previous attempts to keep track have failed, but between festivals, and theatrical and home releases the number easily climbs over 500 each year — and yet there are countless films still to be seen. Obviously the quality of these films vary greatly and most of them are not worth ever mentioning again, but there are a fraction of others whose praises should be shouted from the rooftops. Limiting the list to just 10 can be a struggle; particularly as one debates which picture is most deserving of that final place… thus we also have the honourable mentions section. The only basic restriction imposed here is the film must have played theatrically in North America in 2016; although the proliferation of streaming has generated at least one exception.