A scene from ‘Women Talking’

TIFF ’22 Review: ‘Women Talking’ is a poignant examination of trauma

‘Women Talking’ centres on a group of women who finally decide to put their safety first, but must now weigh the consequences of their actions.

In a tight-knit Mennonite community, several men have been turned over to the authorities for sexually assaulting the village’s women and girls. However, they are far from the only culprits in years of abuse that have been concealed, actively ignored and explained away as acts of ghosts and Satan. Now, the women are at a crossroads and they must choose between three options: do nothing, stay and fight, or leave. After a first-of-its-kind vote, a small group of women are appointed to deliberate their choices. Gathered in a hayloft, the only remaining man, a schoolteacher named August (Ben Whishaw), takes minutes as the women have only two days to decide their fates before the other men return.

Writer/director Sarah Polley has not released a film in a decade, but she returns with a poignant examination of trauma. There are very few sets in the picture, emphasizing that these women are isolated and alone in their stand against the non-discretionary rape that’s occurred (and reoccurred) most of their lives. The subject matter is dealt with in a manner that both underlines its effects, while never explicitly describing the scenes. Polley expertly splices in via brief flashbacks of women waking up frightened, bruised and bleeding, never holding long enough to allow anyone to dwell too long on what was since this is about what will be.

The film begins by noting what follows is an “act of female imagination” as the ability for women to make such choices based purely on self-preservation is so inconceivable – under any circumstances. The cast is exceptional. They cry because there are no other outlets for their pain. They laugh and occasionally poke fun at the absurdity of their situation. They yell and rage at each other because they can’t unleash their fury on the men who deserve it. And they console each other because they’ve all been made victims by these heinous crimes.

Women Talking had its international premiere in the Special Presentations programme at the Toronto International Film Festival.

Read other reviews from the festival and stay tuned for the full review later this year.

Director: Sarah Polley
Starring: Rooney Mara, Claire Foy and Jessie Buckley

Similar Posts

  • Review: ‘Live by Night’ could have benefitted from greater focus (Includes first-hand account)

    The gangster movie has always been a staple of cinema, from the 1930s black-and-white Little Caesar and The Public Enemy to The Godfather, Scarface (remake) and Goodfellas. Audiences are fascinated by the career criminal and his rise to be king of the mountain… before he’s inevitably knocked down by another ambitious crook. The façade that they are simply businessmen that handle more “delicate” merchandise and take a keen interest in managing the competition has always been one of the more intriguing aspects of their personalities — the ability to compartmentalize, rationalize and, when all else fails, deny. Live by Night is slightly more complex as its protagonist has always had higher, more sensitive aspirations.

  • Review: ‘Annabelle: Creation’ is creepy… some of the time (Includes first-hand account)

    As a child, dolls that share the features of its owner — height, hair and eye colour, outfits — are delightful. Seeing themselves reflected in the figures brings them a strange sense of camaraderie that feeds their imaginations. However, as an adult, one begins to view these once charming toys with suspicion. What lurks behind those lifelike eyes that follow you across the room? What evil may possess the doll for its malevolent purposes? In Annabelle: Creation, such distrust comes too late.

  • Review: ‘The Secret Life of Pets’ is the realization of our pet dreams (Includes first-hand account)

    As much as animal lovers like to imagine what the inarticulate creatures are thinking, owners enjoy imagining what their pets do in their absence. Even though most know the truth is as exciting as a really long nap, it’s more fun to envision them living a clandestine second life that will forever remain a secret from the human race. In this latest animated feature, creators take these ideas even further by fashioning a world in which animals communicate between species and have regular gatherings to pass the time. The Secret Life of Pets is a glimpse into this surreptitious realm.

  • Review: ‘London Road’ is paved with innovation and a few potholes (Includes first-hand account)

    Combining genres can have mixed results, but when it works the effect can be profound. The 2000s has seen several mash-ups of horror or the macabre with the traditionally brighter and uplifting musical. Repo! The Genetic Opera and Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street come to mind as examples of genre blending working out wonderfully. But what about less sexy narratives, such as a small town murder mystery? And what if creators took it one step further and used real-life scripts to compose their lyrics? London Road does this and more to produce a unique, tuneful account of a community’s shocking discovery.