A scene from ‘Seven Winters in Tehran’

Hot Docs Review: ‘Seven Winters in Tehran’ is brimming with injustice

‘Seven Winters in Tehran’ follows a young woman sentenced to death for defending herself against a rapist in Iran.

People are regularly confronted by news coverage of and social media campaigns opposing various and specific human rights violations. While countries are expected to have their own laws and traditions, it’s difficult to accept when those rules are designed to disenfranchise and unfairly punish a certain group. In particular, middle-Eastern cultures tend to favour men over women, leading the latter to face harsh punishments for seemingly harmless or reasonable behaviour. In the latest documentary to shed light on an instance of discrimination and injustice, Seven Winters in Tehran follows the case of a young woman who killed her would-be rapist.

In the summer of 2007, Reyhaneh Jabbari was approached by a man who overheard her discussing a design project. Offering her an opportunity to design his new clinic, he invites her to view the space. Unfortunately, this is just a ploy to get the 19-year-old alone to rape her. Jabbari manages to defend herself by stabbing him and escaping. After his death and her arrest, it’s eventually revealed the man was a former agent of the Iranian Ministry of Intelligence. Jabbari is inevitably convicted of his murder and sentenced to death by “blood revenge.” Over the course of seven years, Jabbari is tortured, called a liar, forced to provide a false confession supporting premeditated murder, and told to seek a pardon by retracting her testimony and apologizing to the victim’s family.

It’s important to note this documentary only exists because filmmakers smuggled the footage out of Iran, determined to share Jabbari’s narrative with the world. It’s difficult to listen to her story as she’s repeatedly treated unjustly and the physical threat to her well-being is deliberately dismissed, going as far as to blame her for the attack. Most trying are the suggestions that it would have been better if she’d allowed the rape to occur and the confessions of other young women that they likely would surrender to a rapist now after seeing the consequences of Jabbari protecting herself.

Jabbari’s words are shared via audio recordings and letters in which she speaks very intelligently and candidly about her situation. Her parents, two sisters and lawyer fill in the blanks, describing the complications and distress they experienced as they fought for Jabbari’s freedom, first within the legal system and then through the victim’s family as they begged for forgiveness on her behalf. It’s a harrowing tale for all involved as everything appears to be setup to make her release next to impossible. Overall, this is a compelling true crime narrative that unfolded nearly 10,000 km away, using the facts of the case to call attention to the disparaging state of the country’s women’s rights.

Seven Winters in Tehran had its North American premiere in the Persister programme at the Hot Docs Festival.

Read other reviews from the festival.

Director: Steffi Niederzoll

Similar Posts

  • Review: ‘Sunshine Superman’ soars to great documentary heights (Includes first-hand account)

    While extreme sports are regularly being taken to new levels, the actual practice of pushing the limits and testing boundaries has existed for several decades. And it generally starts with someone asking, “What else could we do?” Sunshine Superman chronicles the life of a man who asked that question in the ‘70s after regular skydiving became too humdrum.

  • Review: Hot Docs’ ‘Screen on Screen’ puts movies at the forefront (Includes first-hand account)

    Going to the cinema is generally considered a form of escape. Just this month, audiences sat shotgun with the team in Fast 7, fell in love for the first time in The Longest Ride, and saw the world through the eyes of acclaimed photographer Sebastião Salgado in The Salt of the Earth. But there are so many ways to experience film; the audience’s experiences will differ widely from the experiences of the actors and crew who made the picture. At the Hot Docs Canadian International Documentary Festival, the “Screen on Screen” program investigates people’s relationships with movies. One of this year’s selections discusses the deliverance some cinephiles found in American productions, while another examines the effects of being a star in the Hollywood system.

  • Review: Hot Docs doesn’t want anyone left in the dark on these issues (Includes first-hand account)

    While not all documentary cinema needs to be serious or enlightening, these films certainly have an important place in the genre. Following the old adage, “a picture is worth a thousand words,” a movie can only further illustrate issues not easily explained or provide evidence of an overarching problem. At Hot Docs Canadian International Documentary Festival, the “silence breakers” programme features films in which its subjects are drawing attention to topics that require our consideration and demonstrating that there are people trying to instil change. And in a slightly different context, a different political commentary was slipped into the “artscapes” category this year.

  • Review: ‘Ramen Heads’ takes soup to a new level at Hot Docs (Includes first-hand account)

    While eating is an unavoidable necessity of sustained life, it has evolved into much more. In the West, where opulence abounds, food is often treated as something to be experienced by all the senses rather than just the means to satisfying a basic need. Competitions and ratings are used to determine local, national and world’s best, and long waits to taste these culinary masterpieces are expected rather than reviled. Consequently the food documentary has gained momentum in recent years, taking audiences into the kitchens of the world’s elite or behind the scenes of the most renowned contests. This year the Hot Docs Canadian International Documentary Festival presents a film called Ramen Heads, which refers to a specific type of food fandom.