A scene from ‘The Luckiest Man in America’

TIFF ’24 Review: ‘The Luckiest Man in America’ is a chronicle of errors

‘The Luckiest Man in America’ follows a man who won the largest ever prize in game show history by gaming the system.

While the American Dream is to be successful, the true goal is to bypass the hard work and make easy money. It’s one of the many reasons the lottery and game shows (and to a different element, robbery and scams) are so popular — the return on investment can be exponential. However, as most people know, leaving things to chance also stacks the odds against them – unless you happen to be incredibly fortunate, skilled and/or clever. The Luckiest Man in America is about a game show contestant who is some combination of these characteristics.

Press Your Luck was a popular game show in the 1980s, lasting four seasons. But in 1984, contestant Michael Larson (Paul Walter Hauser) won the largest prize in game show history in a record-breaking streak of “no whammys.” Originally from Ohio, the man auditions for the show in Los Angeles and in spite of some grave errors, wins over show co-creator Bill Carruthers (David Strathairn) and returns the next day for a taping. He gets off to a slow start, but on his next turn he launches into a hot streak of winning squares and refuses to relinquish control of the board. As Michael’s winnings increase, host Peter Tomarken (Walton Goggins) tries to quell the fire. Meanwhile, everyone in the control booth is sweating bullets since the size of the prize likely has a direct correlation with the odds of them losing their jobs.

Bill’s right-hand man, Chuck (Shamier Anderson), knows there’s something off about Michael, but Bill is convinced his awkward niceties will make good television — after all, the man drives an ice cream truck. He says the right things at the right time, overly polite and apologetic as the need arises. Yet, there’s a temper bubbling beneath the surface and a sense of desperation related to his supposedly picture-perfect family that’s unsettling. Convinced Michael must be cheating somehow, the showrunners begin to dig into his life in the hopes of discovering a connection to an accomplice or a weakness they can exploit to throw him off his game.

It’s unusual to think a movie like this would be suspenseful, particularly since it’s based on a true story and the outcome is predetermined, but there is a mounting tension that permeates the narrative. There’s so much at stake for so many characters, whether it’s a financial windfall or job security. There’s a constant question of, “What will they do next,” either in relation to the showrunners frantically trying to end his streak or Michael deciding when the risk is too great and he’s won enough. Hauser loves portraying these resigned eccentrics, and here he conveys a man whose hopes and dreams rest on this one television appearance, for better or worse.

The Luckiest Man in America had its world premiere in the Special Presentations programme at the Toronto International Film Festival.

Read other reviews from the festival.

Director: Samir Oliveros
Starring: Shamier Anderson, Haley Bennett and Brian Geraghty

Similar Posts

  • Review: ‘Never Look Away’ finds inspiration in all of life’s experiences (Includes first-hand account)

    Since the conclusion of World War II, storytellers have approached the conflict and its fallout from numerous perspectives. Some are less direct than others, opting to follow the path of someone not immediately involved, but affected nonetheless. The repercussions of that particular war were long-lasting as the hunt for high-ranking officials that played key roles in Hitler’s design continued for decades. Consequently, it was often the children who felt the burden of their parents’ sins in post-war Germany. In Never Look Away, life behind the communist wall becomes too difficult to bear.

  • Review: ‘The Hallow’ finds its monster in Irish folklore (Includes first-hand account)

    Urban legends and myths are often curated from generations of oral histories, enduring over the years as silly folktales or widely held superstitions. Most countries generally have their own lore specific to the region with some relating to vampires, werewolves and faeries – stories that were appropriated for books and movies over the years. In Ireland and nearby lands, the natural habitats of mystical creatures are guarded and often avoided to preclude any possible retaliation. Even so, an outsider to the area may not know or believe in the rules, which proves hazardous to everyone in The Hallow.

  • Review: TIFF 2015 — ‘Dégradé’ portrays Gaza from a female point of view (Includes first-hand account)

    While theatre and cinema are related, it can be challenging to apply the rules of one medium to the other — though not impossible. In many ways, the stage has more limitations than film. However, those restrictions can be creatively applied to a movie in a manner that shapes its characters interactions with the world. Not necessarily just for an adaptation of a play, one can construct an original script that is similarly controlled. Results vary, but can be very stimulating. The action of Dégradé is almost entirely confined to a single room with a war unfolding beyond its doors.