Review: ‘The Sisters Brothers’ doesn’t try to abide by tradition (Includes first-hand account)

While the Western’s heyday may have passed, there is no shortage of new entries to the genre, especially of late. The narratives in the category allow for interesting explorations of race and class, as well as greed and justice. The era of gunslingers and gold diggers invites any number of conversations of right and wrong, good people and bad… and what’s right may not always be good, and vice versa. Legends were created as their feats were immortalized in the written word and fame became a goal rather than an abstract idea. This is the world in which The Sisters Brothers unfolds.

Eli and Charlie Sisters (John C. Reilly and Joaquin Phoenix, respectively) are outlaws who’ve spent several years making a name for themselves. Their efforts brought them to be in the employment of The Commodore (Rutger Hauer), who’s claimed much of surrounding territory as his domain and uses their skills to ensure no one gets away with crossing him. Their current assignment involves hunting down a chemist, Herman Kermit Warm (Riz Ahmed), who’s in possession of a formula The Commodore covets. Chasing him across several states and getting updates from their accomplice, John Morris (Jake Gyllenhaal), the Sisters brothers always seem to be two steps behind, which isn’t good for their health in their line of work.

Even though they are siblings and partners, Eli and Charlie couldn’t be more dissimilar from each other. Eli is the eldest and the more level-headed of the two men. He hopes to one day retire, settle down with the woman of his dreams and open a store somewhere quiet. Charlie, on the other hand, is a philanderer who enjoys his drink, spends every dollar they make and can’t imagine doing anything else with his life. Although their gun-fighting skills are matched and superior to most, Eli wouldn’t make his living with a pistol if it wasn’t the path Charlie chose for them. Other than wanting to preserve his younger brother, Eli feels he owes Charlie a debt he can never repay — an unexpected source of emotion that runs through the entire film.

In the parallel story, John is incredibly well-spoken and good-mannered. He keeps a diary of his adventures and doesn’t really seem like a gun-for-hire. Herman also has a higher education, which allows him and John to connect on a level neither usually can with other men. Though the latter would be better off if he adopted some of John’s caution when it comes to enlightening people about his grand idea to strike it rich. While John and Herman seem better suited to a partnership, their relationship is built on an inherent deception that will eventually come to a head.

Everyone nails their parts, complementing each other’s performances in spite of the differences in their characters. The gunfights are exciting and pick-up as the story continues, while also finding room for some intrinsic comedy. Moreover, there are elements of the narrative that don’t seem pertinent to the overall plot, yet add to the film’s personality. Finally, the conclusion is pretty brutal as the definition of comeuppance is tested and the four men discover nothing can shield them from the horrors of their actions.

Hitman. Big brother. Gentle soul. John C. Reilly is Eli Sisters. Go see #TheSistersBrothers, NOW PLAYING in NY and LA – additional cities to follow: pic.twitter.com/2HI4CgJ35u

— The Sisters Brothers (@SistersBrosFilm) September 22, 2018

Director: Jacques Audiard
Starring: John C. Reilly, Joaquin Phoenix and Jake Gyllenhaal

Similar Posts

  • Review: ‘Shingal, Where Are You?’ brings faces of genocide to Hot Docs (Includes first-hand account)

    “Genocide” is almost a dirty word that no one wants to utter — not because it’s not occurring in multiple countries around the world, but because of the obligation its acknowledgment places on foreign powers. With the promise after WWII that it would never be permitted to happen again, labelling any massacre as such requires a response. In 2014 Daesh (ISIS) began a brutal campaign against the Yazidis in Iraq, killing thousands of men, imposing forced religious conversion, and kidnapping thousands of women and girls for sexual slavery. They were eventually deemed to be acts of genocide by the United Nations and United States. The documentary, Shingal, Where Are You?, follows a family displaced by the conflict.

  • Review: Clint Eastwood delivers a great film in ‘Richard Jewell’ (Includes first-hand account)

    While the American justice system is supposed to be built on the idea that everyone is innocent until proven guilty, it often doesn’t work that way. For one, law enforcement can become so focused on a single suspect, they view all the evidence through a lens of bias. Second, many suspects are often tried by the media and public opinion before they even step foot in a courtroom. Finally, if it turns out the prime suspect is innocent, it’s often decided only after their reputation has suffered irreparable damage. For Richard Jewell, his 15 minutes of fame turns into a never-ending nightmare overnight in this true story.

  • Review: ‘Dark Phoenix’ goes up in flames (Includes first-hand account)

    Fans of the Phoenix saga generally came to the story in one of two ways: through the X-Men comics or via the ‘90s animated TV series. The last couple of attempts to incorporate the fiery narrative into the film franchise didn’t amount to very much and definitely didn’t do the epic storyline justice. Now, they’ve given the immensely powerful mutant her own picture in which to explore her abilities and unleash the rage that accompanies it. But it’s not all fire and brimstone as there’s a lot of complex emotions to deal with as well. Dark Phoenix tries to encapsulate all of these things while telling one of the superheroes’ most beloved narratives.